Game of Mafia

EscapedConvict

With regard to the EC's campaign of keeping Moxy around until he proves himself, I think Gridfon made some really valid points. Please don't put words in my mouth. I never said Moxy can prove his innocence. You won't be able find a quote from me that would say that. I replied to Gridfon's points an...

EscapedConvict

Updated vote count: 10 required for deadline lynch 2 hours left ! . As things stand right now Moxy will be lynched. Moxy 11 (blissie, radwulf, phox, princess.ruxi, SilveXtru, behemoth, zero, Mary, Bombaclaat, valli, MrWaffles) Trigardon 5 (rene, Skuggi, Moxy, Heffie, Gridfon) radwulf 4 (Adela, Strin...

EscapedConvict

Original Post:
less then 3 hours left

Acceptable Post:
less then 3 hours left

[edit by Daemon]

EscapedConvict

..but currently the people I trust most are Joesatri, Mary, Gridfon and Stringer in order. May I ask why Mary? And EscapedConvict it's good that we see things eye to eye, but I just feel neutral to you at the moment Feeling is mutual. I liked the fact that you spoke freely and coherently against th...

EscapedConvict

And what're the odds that Moxy has not one, not two but three night time abilities and also is a killer? Very good point. And I will bring back what radwulf said about Moxy in one of his last posts by trying again to throw me under the bus: No, it's a bad idea borne out of EC's desperation at losin...

EscapedConvict

Moxy is probably their Godfather. Moxy will die unless people back up on their votes, and that will look heavenly suspicious. So no one will do that. I disagree. A viable alternative was offered by myself and rene to keep Moxy alive for the town's benefit. There is still time to reconsider. princes...

EscapedConvict

Updated vote count (corrected the Trigardon vote mistake. He recently changed his vote to No Lynch): 10 required for deadline lynch 4 hours left ! . As things stand right now Moxy will be lynched. Moxy 10 (blissie, radwulf, phox, princess.ruxi, SilveXtru, behemoth, zero, Mary, Bombaclaat, valli) Tri...

EscapedConvict

Updated vote count: 10 required for deadline lynch 4 hours left ! . As things stand right now Moxy will be lynched. Moxy 11 (Trigardon, blissie, radwulf, phox, princess.ruxi, SilveXtru, behemoth, zero, Mary, Bombaclaat, valli) Trigardon 5 (rene, Skuggi, Moxy, Heffie, Gridfon) radwulf 5 (Adela, Strin...

EscapedConvict

How can Moxy block the mafia killing? 1. Mafia players usually designate the one to carry out the kill, and they can choose a mafia member who is not blocked. Depends, the mod can designate. (Godfather) 2. According to Moxy's description of his role, it seems he blocks only the outgoing NTAs of his...

EscapedConvict

Never said, Moxy can "prove" anything. Not sure where you got that from. Go back and re-read my post/posts. I just said the town can benefit from his ability. I might be guilty of collating your sentiment with the more explicit suggestions of "proving" things as voiced by other people. But the gene...

EscapedConvict

I think even if Trigardon is innocent, blocking him and then seeing a kill would clear up his name (at least makes him less suspicious). If they pass on the chance to blame Trigardon, that means one more person lives . Which is why I think he's the best option, I don't think he'll get lynched eithe...

EscapedConvict

Moxy wrote: ↑
Thu Apr 16, 2020 2:10 pm
That don’t make sense I’m in pole position to be lynched not Trig

It's why I'm pushing to have people pitch in to the idea to keep you alive and use your ability.
We only have 6 hours left of Day 1.

Everyone that voted for Moxy: can we have you take please? and fast.

EscapedConvict

And, yes, I am, I'm just trying to get your take on the matter. I disregarded your suggestion (until you pointed to me) because I see no substance to it, and I see no way to fix it. The latter means I also think that trying to work out a successful "keep Moxy around so he can prove his NTA" strateg...

EscapedConvict

Yeah, I don't really trust radwulf either. And blocking him could be good. But I find It better to block Trigardon to put a softlock on the ongoing events. We, as the town are, already thinking no deaths happened because Trigardon was blocked as a possibility. So what does that mean? It means 1.) T...

EscapedConvict

One fact remains: Moxy can block NTAs (until proven otherwise) Wouldn't it be wise to keep him around and we the town chose who to block every night? The town would have that weapon. Even if Moxy is a psycho/traitor. We use him to our benefit. I will not vote Moxy and I strongly suggest people reco...

EscapedConvict

EC, we don't need pacts with the devil, thanks. What we need is clarity for the town's Night 2 and Day 2's discussions, especially in this game where we may be facing a very unconventional threat. You two's not so subtle last-ditch efforts to keep the Godfather alive are noted though. See even the ...

EscapedConvict

One fact remains: Moxy can block NTAs (until proven otherwise) Wouldn't it be wise to keep him around and we the town chose who to block every night? The town would have that weapon. Even if Moxy is a psycho/traitor. We use him to our benefit. I will not vote Moxy and I strongly suggest people reco...

EscapedConvict

No, it's a bad idea borne out of EC's desperation at losing his Godfather on day 1. The town is divided and uncertain right now. A successful lynch would bring tremendous value to the accuracy of NIGHT 2 actions. Right now we are not united enough for a lynch, no way there's enough consensus to dir...

EscapedConvict

Rene wrote: I'm also in huge favour of keeping Moxy alive as long as we get to choose who they block at night after a day time vote, great idea actually EscapedConvict.

Radwulf? Behemouth?

EscapedConvict

One fact remains: Moxy can block NTAs (until proven otherwise) Wouldn't it be wise to keep him around and we the town chose who to block every night? The town would have that weapon. Even if Moxy is a psycho/traitor. We use him to our benefit. I will not vote Moxy and I strongly suggest people recon...

EscapedConvict

Why am I not surprised that when it counts, EC is not willing to vote for whom I presume to be his Godfather, despite his stated certainty? Still reading the comments from today And as rene pointed, its a good question to asked ourselves if there is anything to gain from keeping Moxy alive one more...

EscapedConvict

MrWaffles wrote: ↑
Thu Apr 16, 2020 12:12 pm
I feel we should wait till tonight to see if Moxy's earlier assertions about his NTAs can be proven. If something turns out to be false, we can still 50% lynch him and anyone else we want tomorrow as I think there is no cap on instant lynchings in a day.

Good point.

EscapedConvict

I don't get the point of immediately turning at Moxy. I by no means, back them up, well it's impossible to do so given how much attention they brought to themselves. But we know two night time abilities at play and they are both confirmed, because of their reveal. Whether they belong to innocent Mo...

EscapedConvict

Now to the topic of EscapedConvict vs. radwulf :) EC - Your relentless grilling of radwulf seems disproportionate to his alleged missteps. There are players with much deeper holes in their reasoning and more glaring inconsistencies. Either he brings out in you some primeval male instinct of wanting...

EscapedConvict

I can absolutely confirm this. But who says he blocked something evil instead of something good! Moxy was holding prejucides in the first NTA, so it's not surprise his first LYNCH vote was going towards me. Ok then...I think everyone should withdraw their votes on Trigardon for now.. Unfortunately ...

EscapedConvict

True on both counts, phox, thanks REVISED COUNT - if someone cast a new vote but they didn't unvote I counted it and removed the previous vote (some people did forget to unvote) - I added Adela vote for radwulf in post #24. I think the mod should decide if it counts or not. wrong format .but she did...

EscapedConvict

and of course I misspelled a few names...mod, please, edit

EscapedConvict

Alright, here's a count with whom voted for whom and in what order also: - I did meticulously go through the whole thread so I think it's pretty accurate. - if someone cast a new vote but they didn't unvote I counted it and removed the previous vote (some people did forget to unvote) - I didn't coun...

EscapedConvict

Vote count
(based on Joesatri's last count):
(can't guarantee it's 100% accurate)

6 Moxy
6 Trigardon
4 Radwulf
3 NO LYNCH
1 Behemoth
1 Blissie
1 EscapedConvict
1 Mary
1 Valli

An official vote count would be nice that includes who voted for whom.

EscapedConvict

Vote count please?

FYI, less then 23 hours remain in Day 1.

EscapedConvict

QUESTION FOR THE MODERATOR : Daemon, was this rule changed at the time of your post quoted below or was it changed before the game started? At certain of our peers' behest, that rule requiring a minimum amount of votes before allowing players to require role claims from others has been removed. (Ju...

EscapedConvict

QUESTION FOR THE MODERATOR : Daemon, was this rule changed at the time of your post quoted below or was it changed before the game started? At certain of our peers' behest, that rule requiring a minimum amount of votes before allowing players to require role claims from others has been removed. (Ju...

EscapedConvict

4. Is it OK for a townie (especially a veteran) to ask another player (especially another veteran) for a role claim so early on if it's not a pre-lynch last chance situation? 4. Sure. You are free to ignore it if others don't find merit in the accusations. In what way does that harm the town? Espec...

EscapedConvict

Yeah, my vote stays.

EscapedConvict

Heffie, noted. You got my attention now. Radwulf, let's go back to the truth before you try to bend it even more. Answer these questions please, for the record, with a simple Yes or No: 1. Is it true you said it was a good idea that I reveal my role after me posting just twice and having just 3 vote...

EscapedConvict

PS : like someone else pointed out already, yes, I did not like radwulf's and behemoth's very early role claim requests from me. it's not, especially, in radwulf's character to do that to me as a townie so early on and based on so little info (to put it in context for people that do not know, me an...

EscapedConvict

You were referring to me and my situation. Here is the full quote from you again: Wrong. Read that ENTIRE post again, including the quote I was replying to: It seems like radwulf saw an opening to push Moxy to reveal his role, and took the opportunity. Not gonna fly. You mentioned my name. Why? And...

EscapedConvict

Since you insist upon radwulf, what exactly has he done other than trying to get the game going on page 1? Just want to ensure I didn't miss something. Demand a role from me on page one after I posted twice and then trying to pass it on as needed because it was a "pre-lynch last chance" situation A...

EscapedConvict

Suspect me? Sure. Asking for a role on he first page after I posted twice and then trying to justify it by saying that it was a pre-lynch last chance situation? Nope. You're taking my words from the context of Moxy's situation (a significant bandwagon had formed there) and maliciously applying them...

EscapedConvict

radwulf , there is an undeniable difference between you believing I'm guilty (even that is highly questionable on the begining of first day after I posted just once and had just 3 random votes) and a " pre-lynch last chance " situation when a role claim makes sense. I'm sorry, but you were caught. ...

EscapedConvict

Heffie , the ability to send messages was confirmed by Skuggi. (yes Skuggi can lie but no reason to do that at this point and associate yourself with someone that is on the brink of being lynched) So that results in the fact that Moxi is most likely lying when it comes to the 2nd NTA of blocking pe...

EscapedConvict

radwulf , there is an undeniable difference between you believing I'm guilty (even that is highly questionable on the begining of first day after I posted just once and had just 3 random votes) and a " pre-lynch last chance " situation when a role claim makes sense. I'm sorry, but you were caught. ...

EscapedConvict

Heffie , the ability to send messages was confirmed by Skuggi. (yes Skuggi can lie but no reason to do that at this point and associate yourself with someone that is on the brink of being lynched) So that results in the fact that Moxi is most likely lying when it comes to the 2nd NTA of blocking pe...

EscapedConvict

Because I believe Moxy cannot kill at night. Only has the ability to confuse and throw people off with his night time message sending ability. What is that belief based on? On the fact that I chose to believe he does not have 2 NTAs. And the first one (sending messages) was confirmed already by Sku...

EscapedConvict

Post #243 EC, I always rub you the wrong way from the start. From my perspective, yes: you were (and are) lynch-worthy. To your dossier we can now add the intent to kill someone who is probably under a night-time directive, instead of voting off the proven liar. For the record that's #241 And no, y...

EscapedConvict

I think you're referring to #234 As for role claim demands, it is standard pre-lynch protocol, to give someone very suspicious a last chance to prove their innocence and retrieve any night knowledge they may have in case they do get lynched. Escaped Convict should know that. but that is, at best, an...

EscapedConvict

EscapedConvict: I did respond to that, see my second sentence in post #243. #243 is not your post. Please quote your response. If you belive Moxy to be a psycho, the most logical thing for you to do right now is vote him off. You'd be eliminating one killing entity with one lynch. The best bang for...

EscapedConvict

FYI, only 27 hours left of Day 1

EscapedConvict

EC, what accusation have I not answered? The one below (requesting a role way too early on): I wonder where is radfwulf now. He was pretty vocal, went as far as calling Moxy liar and scum, and begged us all to lynch Moxy... and was pushing hard for Moxy to reveal his role. Now, once that is done, r...

EscapedConvict

to me, Moxy looks more and more like a traitor/psycho type of role (still baddie). Not straight up mafia.

Search found 229 matches